Thursday, August 4, 2011

Assessment and Singapore

I taught first grade for seven years. In those seven years, 3 times a year my students were scheduled in the computer lab for a standardized test. It was test that all students in my school also took at the beginning, middle, and end of the school year. There was a test for each grade level that assessed language arts skills, reading skills, and math skills. I definitely find flaws in this assessment method for many reasons.

First, all children learn and test in different manners. If we know that we have to gear our teaching to meet all the diverse needs of our students, then why should be assessing them all in one way? Second, not all children are at the same level with their use of technology. We can’t assume that all children are able to use a computer, mouse, and headphones in an accurate manner. Finally, assessing only three academic areas does not aid in assessing the child as a whole. There are so many more things to a child than academic performance. Observation is a great way to assess other aspects that can be beneficial in overall performance such as behavior, social skills, and emotional intelligence.

As an educator, I always knew it was my part to assess my students’ performance in many ways. Sometimes you need to look at the child in whole group, small group, or individually. Other times, you need to use verbal assessing or observation. I will honestly admit that I never put too much trust into the performance of my students on standardized testing, and I am not sure why so many people think this is the only way to assess our students.



When I started looking up info about viewing children holistically, a lot of information about education in Singapore came up. Educators in Singapore have made many changes over the last few years to move to a more holistic approach to education. An article from The Washington Post quoted Prime Minister Lee of Singapore as he spoke about the approach in Singapore. He said;

“I think we should do more to nurture the whole child, develop their physical robustness, enhance their creativity, shape their personal and cultural and social identity, so that they are fit, they are confident, they are imaginative and they know who they are.

Every child is different, every child has his own interests, his own academic inclinations and aptitudes and our aim should be to provide him with a good education that suits him, one which enables him to achieve his potential and build on his strengths and talents. Talent means talent in many dimensions, not just academic talent but in arts, in music, in sports, in creative activities, in physical activities.

We need to pay more attention to PE, to arts and music and get teachers who are qualified to teach PE and art and music.

Give each one a tailored and holistic upbringing, so you get academic education, moral education, physical education, art and a sense of belonging and identity. We aim to build a mountain range with many tall peaks but with a high base, not just a single pinnacle where everybody is trying to scramble up one single peak. And we are realizing this vision."

It would make sense that their teaching and assessment would both be geared toward a holistic approach. I also visited the Ministry of Singapore to read a little more in-depth about the education system there. I find their approach very interesting and refreshing. If you have a change you can visit the website by clicking here.

*Source*

4 comments:

  1. Kristen, I definitely agree with all of your points, and I don't have the experience that you have in regards to testing, so it was good to hear your views on it. My aunt is a reading specialist, and she always calls it "No Child Left Untested". I didn't even think about your point of children not having the experience to use a computer, which I guess was naive of me. But even a child at a young age could have a difficult time. And thank you for all of your information on Singapore!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree with your view on testing. Very good idea about focusing on the arts and music too! I have always been a visual learner and loved art growing up, and that is where I excelled in, never the "academic" portion of school or math, language arts, etc. Your observation point is a great one! I personally feel that is like automatic pilot for me, but we need to do more of that, then theses assessment testing. Thanks for sharing! Very interesting about Singapore too, seems that in other countries have an interesting approach on all this too.

    ReplyDelete
  3. During our field day in May we discovered our children did not know how to jump rope, hulla hop, or even skip in kindergarten. We found fifth graders who did not know the rules of basketball. Our students go to P.E every week but it is obvious they are not being properly taught physical skills. So I love your comment about paying more attention to PE, to arts and music and get teachers who are qualified to teach PE and art and music. It is vital for our kids to be well rounded!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think to much emphasis is placed on Standerdized test. I believe that the child has a variety of ways that they can show us that they have had a successful year, we just have to be able to tap into it and use it to our advantage.

    ReplyDelete